What all fans have been talking about was David Tennant handing the reins over to Matt Smith; to the point where that’s all they talked about- on the internet, during dinner, in the middle of sex, to long suffering spouses and pretty much any poor soul they could find. In some respect you couldn’t blame them, in their eyes Tennant had become almost like a member of the family. With his 5th season playing The Doctor essentially becoming a five episode farewell tour, everything has built up to this epic but foolishly aired finale.
With all the intense media fellatio regarding the departure of the 10th Doctor, many overlook the fact that this is farewell to Russell T. Davies, the creative force who took the franchise from rusting in drydock to ratings smash. Davies doesn’t pass up a chance to tie up all the loose ends of the past five years into one dense, a grandly dramatic au revoir. The plot of “The End of Time” could easily fit into another five or six episodes, but all Davies has is two so everything gets shoehorned into one script, for good or ill. Could be worse, since the original series was abruptly cancelled after an episode unfortunatly titled “Survival”. Anything’s better than a last hurrah like that.
Suffice to say, The Master is rather improbably resurrected and The Doctor races to stop him from whatever the hell he’s up to now. His final companion is Wilfred Noble, grandfather to Donna Noble, who finally gets his wish to see the Earth from orbit and travel in space. They encounter a meglomanical billionare and a piece of alien tech called ”The Immortality Gate”, a wacky duo of alien salvagers, The Master literally erasing the human race from the universe, and the return of the Time Lords and Gallifrey. The 10th Doctor regenerates in an unusually drawn out spectacular fashion, and his makeover reveals a boyishly enthusiastic persona that’s instantly likeable in the closing minutes. Series veteran Nicholas Briggs and Brian Cox (X2, Red Eye, Manhunter) provide nice invisible cameos as voices for a Judoon and the Ood Elder.
Director Euros Lyn does an amazing job keeping it all flowing in a coherent fashion; there’s a ton of exposition that could easily bog everything down, but he manages to make a landmark episode worthy of being called landmark. Davies resolves pretty much all the dangling plot threads neatly enough, although the resolution to Donna Noble’s character seems hastily conceived. Nice bits include the brief allusion to the stone angels from “Blink”, closure to The Doctor’s love from “Family Blood”, the truth of The Master’s pounding drums, and the revelation of who will be responsible for the death of the last Time Lord. The return of The Doctor’s homeworld is also staged well, as is turning the show’s mythology on its’ ear by reinventing the Time Lords as genocidal dictators, whose final solution to the Time War was the destruction of the Time Vortex and reality itself.
What truly hampers “The End of Time” was the decision to show it in two parts as opposed to simply one two hour plus special. There’s just so much going on it’s a bit hard to keep track of it over the course of a week, a lot is lost in viewer’s minds by the time part two airs. Actions that make little sense in part one are clarified in part two, but the seven day gap causes the dramatic impact to fall flat. Watching the entire episode in one sitting allows you fully appreciate the end of a “Doctor Who” era, and give a sneak peek at a new one full of promise.
There’s really no point in saying Matt Smith has his work cut out for him, that’s like saying the sky is blue and water is wet. Any idiot with access to BBC America can see that. We’ve been left with a cliffhanger, as the TARDIS sustained critical damaged during the regeneration process, and is hurtling on a crash course towards Earth. The 11th Doctor is trying to regain his bearing while trying to regain control of his ship as all manner of things spark and flame around him. Best of all, he seems like he’s having a blast the entire time.




I enjoyed the second part, despite all its flaws, but the first part felt like an hour of my life wasted. It’s going to be interesting to see what Moffatt and Smith do with it. I have a feeling it’s going to be a much improved show but, perhaps with lower viewing figures. I hope I’m wrong about the viewing figures.
What a superb show!!! I like the show from then when Moffat, who takes over the previous lead writer and producer. In this show Moffat has shown his focus on the characters and their relationships. He has made this show more interesting and I really admire him.
I for one was happy to see the end of the RTD era; the direction he took the series played more like fanfic (and not good fanfic) as time went on — and Rose was his Mary Sue. The relationship between Rose and the Ninth Doctor was terrific; between Rose and the Tenth, unbearable.
This was not the respective actors’ faults! Rose was a terrific companion — for the Ninth Doctor. Tennant was a terrific Doctor. The fault lies with the person providing the overall direction for the show: Davies. The giggly-cute behavior through Season 28 (call it series 2 if you like, but there were 26 seasons before Eccleston came along!!) grew more and more annoying with every episode until I actually cheered breaking up the team at the end of the season.
Martha was a good companion, but the show that year was hampered by extremely uneven writing — from the highs of ‘Human Nature/Family of Blood’ and ‘Blink’ and ‘Utopia’ to the lows of ‘The Shakespeare Code’ and ‘Gridlock’ and ‘Last of the Time Lords’. The end of the Davies era came for me with ‘Last of the Time Lords’ and the resolution that can only be described as “clap your hands and believe real hard and Tinkerbell… er, The Doctor will be okay”. The show recovered a bit when Catherine Tate came on board full time, only to be beaten back to death with ‘The Stolen Earth/Journey’s End’ and Rose saving the day and getting her own broken Doctor to keep. The embarrassing second half of ‘The Next Doctor’ only served to dance on the grave — all the more so since the first half was some of the best Who in a long time.
I am, however, optimistic. Moffat has consistently been the best writer the show has had, so I’m inclined to trust his instincts. The look of the new Doctor reminds me (in a very good way) of the Second Doctor. I think Moffat will have the ship righted in short order.