Avatar (2009) Movie Review

Right away I’m going to tell you that my biggest challenge in writing this review of “Avatar” is to keep my gushing to a minimum. A task that is going to be almost impossible. “Avatar” blew doors off that I didn’t even know I had on the car.

I saw “Avatar” last night at my local IMAX in maximum impact 3D. Your experiences in other 3D or 2D presentations may differ. I went two hours early and was second in line (drat!).  I thought I knew what I was in for. You’ll think you are prepared. You are not prepared. “Avatar” is a brand new movie going experience. It is shock and awe. It is not the technological and story telling evolution I was expecting. Instead, it is a revolution. Go ahead and roll your eyes. I was a little cynical too. How could this movie possibly exceed the almost ridiculous expectations piled on top of it? I’ll tell you how. James Cameron is an insane genius.

James Cameron says that “Avatar” is the movie he has wanted to see since he was a kid. Watching “Avatar”, you can tell that this movie is the movie he has wanted to create from that day too. There’s a slice of all of Cameron’s previous works in “Avatar”. You’ve got tough chicks, bad ass space marines, sweet bioluminescence and some full frontal, hardcore, Disney style feelgood. James Cameron is a sentimental guy and I love it. Cynical, ironic movies suck. I’ve heard reviews say the storyline and some dialogue borders or sails across the line into cheese. These people can bite me. The emotions expressed in this movie are strong I’ll grant you. It’s unfiltered, like real life. When faced with this stuff in a movie you have to ask yourself. Am I being talked down to? Do I believe that the director and writer (both Jim) believe in the temperature and purpose of the feelings being expressed by the characters? I do believe Jim feels it. Next, are the emotions being expressed an honest and accurate depiction of what people in those exact situations would really be feeling? I’d say that is definitely the case.

The story of “Avatar” is kind of a combination of “Dances With Wolves”, “The Lion King” and pick your favorite Sci-fi military epic. About the “Dances With Wolves” bit. If I have any criticism at all of “Avatar” it’s that the Na’Vi couldn’t possibly be closer in feel and cultural identity to that of the American Indian. It’s not even remotely subtle. Though obviously the blue skinned, largish, cat people of Pandora don’t look like American Indians, they sure feel and act the part, at least as far as the limited and maybe wrong representations I’ve experienced in say “Dances With Wolves” for instance. When the Na’Vi did their war whoops, I kind of winced honestly. As alien and wonderful as Pandora is, I think that James could have worked a little harder in making the Na’Vi a little more culturally unique. James has said he wanted the Na’Vi to be immediately likable and identifiable. He might have tried a little too hard.

Now, about the effort that our man James has made. I’ve written about the wonderful things that obsession to vision in a movie or artwork can bring before and James is now the new poster boy for single minded perfectionism. “Avatar”, at least in 3D, is the most beautiful movie ever made. The level of detail in every frame is insane. The only comparison you can find is in real life. However, as you might have heard, Pandora is not a real place, it’s an alien jungle moon and completely computer generated. It looks completely real. “Avatar” could be a National Geographic special. Ok, I’m starting to gush. I could simply not believe what I was seeing shot to shot. I didn’t think it was technically possible. “Avatar” in 2D is going to be, I’m sure, nifty entertainment. 3D “Avatar”, especially IMAX 3D, has ruined me forever. I can’t imagine a better movie viewing experience. James Cameron’s 3D is 3D as it was dreamt of being. It places you physically in the movie. The natural world of Pandora, it’s epic plants and animals and the unbelievably vivid action scenes are right in your face. It makes the previous phrase “You are there”, completely meaningless.

You’ve heard the basic story of “Avatar” by now. A former Marine with a spinal injury, Jake Sully, (The great action hero Sam Worthington) gets a free ride to Pandora after his twin brother, a scientist, dies before getting to go to Pandora where he was trained to be a virtual driver of a vat grown Na’Vi, especially engineered to be driven by a particular person, with whom the freshly cooked ten foot tall Na’Vi physically resembles. Jake arrives after a five year voyage, plugs in with the help of Dr.Grace Augustine played by Sigourney Weaver, who is just one of the many strong female characters that rock in “Avatar”. After Jake gets his sea legs he’s into the jungle where he gets separated from his fellow humans and other human driven Na’Vi by some jaw dropping indigenous nasties. He’s soon picked up by his future bride, the Na’Vi Neytiri, played by Zoe Saldana. Jake basically lets “Dances With Wolves” lead him from there. He learns to hunt, walk in the trees, ride a small dragon thing and fights to get the respect of the tribe and to regain the respect for himself. Of course we have some bad guys on hand led by the criminally under used actor Stephan Lang, who are on the planet in the first place to dig up a juicy mineral that will power a dying Earth. The local Na’Vi tribe, now part time home to Jake, has a massive deposit of this mineral right under their feet. The tribe is either got to move or Colonel Miles Quaritch (Lang) is going to move them with environmentally unfriendly methods involving massive application of mechanized and aerial firepower.

The rest of the story goes as you might expect. Despite it’s predictability, the story thrills and the last quarter of the movie is a teary, eye blasted experience. So obviously I loved “Avatar” and you need to go see it. Bring a friend. Bring a friend then go again and bring a different friend. I predict some heavy repeat business. My wife, who accompanied me, said that despite the pew pew and testosterone, the movie had some excellent chick flick moments. I noticed these and as a fella, they did not terrify me as they usually do. James Cameron has worked a miracle here in many ways. So how does anyone beat this movie is the question? Unless someone gives James a billion dollars to make a “Blade Runner” sequel in 3D, “Avatar” is simply going to reign as champion for a long, long time. I suspect Oscar nominators are going to have to give this movie a nod of well earned respect. As an overall movie going experience “Avatar” is the most impactful movie presentation I have personally witnessed and by itself makes the case to someday buy a 3D television to be able to once again experience James Cameron’s effort in the manner in which he intended it be experienced.

James Cameron (director) / James Cameron (screenplay)
CAST: Sam Worthington … Jake Sully
Zoe Saldana … Neytiri
Sigourney Weaver … Dr. Grace Augustine
Stephen Lang … Colonel Miles Quaritch
Joel Moore … Norm Spellman (as Joel David Moore)
Giovanni Ribisi … Parker Selfridge
Michelle Rodriguez … Trudy Chacon
Laz Alonso … Tsu’tey
Wes Studi … Eytukan


  • Zornik

    I saw the movie last night in Belgium (3D) and was blown away.I was a bit sceptic about the transition between real actors and CGI but in 3D the transition was almost perfect.The story was a bit simplistic (i understand it’s for a wide audience)but the characters are nice and the emotions (even for the CGI characters) r so damn real!!!
    James Cameron made a good example that you need to ‘love’ a character before you can start to care.When you care for a character the action (danger) scenes are that more trilling.This fact is the basic for a good movie but a lot of directors forget this?Cameron is one of the pioniers to make believable sci fi movies with real characters and real emotions…Avatar is no exception.

  • mark

    I saw this in real 3d (whatever that is) and I seriously just cannot believe how any person wouldn’t like this movie. This is the most blown away by a movie I have ever felt. The closest thing to this would be Return of the King in theaters for the first time, but this beats that. I completely lost myself in the movie.

  • Mirko

    What could I say, the man is gifted, who could criticise such creativity.
    This movie technologically has opened the doors to unimaginable possibilities.
    The movie also should make us aware of the balance between all living things.

    A must see movie. Seen it twice so far, BRILLIANT!

  • http://indoku.org Donny

    Heyy!!

    I have seen this movie two weeks ago and I must say that this movie is fascinating..!!

    I love the story and the effects are marvelous..!!

    Two thumbs up!!

    You must see this movie..!!

  • http://www.r4i-kaart.be r4i kaart

    Movie was simply great everyone must see it because..”Avatar” may well be a perfect film to desensitize young audiences before they get the call-up.

  • Andy

    This movie was an absolute marvel to watch. The emotions and just the scenes themselves left me boggling my mind for answers. If you have not seen this movie definitely go see it right away. It will blow you off your feet.

  • Goldie

    I watched this movie today and I cryed yes cryed at its beauty.I know that sounds crazy but you just have to see it to believe it.I had goosebumps for 5 minutes after leaving the movie. I defy anyone to see this movie and not like it.If I could score it I would give it 100 out of 10 if that were possible.

  • Normandy

    My Review:

    THE story itself:

    well its dancing with wolfs, meets last samurai, with lashings of last
    of the Mohicans, and sky-land chucked in, there is NOTHING original or
    very engaging in the story itself… its all been done before, the
    story 4/10!

    The visual effects:

    .. if you can call it that.. its finally come to the moment where CGI
    can NOT be told apart from real life, if you were not told that most
    of this movie is in a computer you would have thought that it was real
    life actors in blue body paint, and a jungle some where, but to see
    that this was CGI was amazing, it makes any CGI before it look like a
    PS3 game. Amazing effort, and this will drive many movies in the
    future having totally photorealistic CGI people etc. 10/10!

    the 3d:

    while it worked for the most part, many times looking over cliff
    walls, and zipping down mountains made me have vertigo…. AND SOME
    scenes were plain breathtaking in a way no movie has ever done before.
    Cameron didn’t try to Push it all in your face, like 3D has tried to
    do before, it was very immersive…..HOWEVER I HAD SOME ISSUES… many
    scenes with fast motion were blurry, and ghosting, and 5 hours afters,
    half my family felt sick or have headaches and were very tried. I so
    hope this is not going mainstream, its not like it makes the story any
    better, and acts as a bit of gimmick, and I don’t like feeling sick
    after a movie thanks James Cameron. 4/10

    so over all 6/10…

    at 21 bucks a ticket (1 dollar for the 3d glasses).. I think just go
    see the 2d version if you don’t like being on a roller coaster for 3
    hours… or wait for the DVD… its nothing you haven’t seen before..
    except the CGI.. which really is totally amazing, as it doesn’t look
    like CGI.. it looks like real life.

    I wont be going to movies to see it again, as its way too expensive. I
    will get it when its out , as I think it will look good (no where near
    as great as 3d on a big screen). I still like Abyss as Camerons best
    work. If you never seen 3D, then this is the movie to see 3D in, as
    its the best 3D I have seen so far.. but it still needs improvement…

    • http://www.scificool.com/avatar-2009-movie-review/ Jeff

      whoever you are; your opinion proves you are after attention rather than being honest. Stop reading other pompus reviews and try to be honest. The movie was created to be entertaining, not Shakespeare

      • Normandy

        I just expected more in terms of story. ie, like transformers, I knew what I was getting robot on robot action, great cgi, action, things blowing up. I guess this suffered from its own hype, I was expecting more in terms of a story, rather than a re-hash of 3-4 others, and not executed that well. Did it entertain me, yes, was its a masterpiece of cinema? No.

        I am being honest in my review, if you don’t agree, thats fine, but dont attack some one for attention seeking as they dont agree, when they are just being honest.

        WAY TOO many people are claiming this the finest bit of cinema to ever exist, which i think is sad, as for me the best bits of cinema are that that have very fine stories, with some excellent acting, the visual come a big second for me. Where this was lots of style but little beneath the surface, I prefer to have my mind stretched for it to hold a claim of best bit of cinema ever, and this goes in the category like transformers, all flash, little story. Which is the way cinema is going, big blockbusters with budgets the size of small countries economy spent on cgi (2012 anyone?) but are the same old re-hash of ideas rather than anything original.

      • Jeff (The other one)

        Uh, dude, by it’s own definition, an “opinion” can prove nothing.

        However, your post proves that you are sort of rude. If Normandy wants to expound or (as you said) be “pompous”, so what? You don’t HAVE to read any post you don’t wish to.

        Sidenote: Shakespeare wrote his plays for profit and created them to be “entertaining”. That they’ve stood the test of time merely shows he was very succesful in his endeavours.

        No need to respond in anger, because this reply was not written in anger. Just try to be a little more tolerant of we little people who aren’t quite as smart as you obviously are.

        • http://www.scificool.com/avatar-2009-movie-review/ Jeff

          you have shown me the light. Bless you

        • http://www.scificool.com/avatar-2009-movie-review/ Jeff

          Uh dude, my intellectual movie-mate and one prone to lecture excessively. By your own words ‘an opinion can prove nothing’. Why react to me? Assuming you are the ‘reply police’, please read rather then react. I stated Normandy should stop READING popmpous reviews. Regurgitating other opinions is a waste of space. As for anger, read what you write. Another opinion……..

          • normandy

            I have not been reading any pompous reviews. Having a differing opinion is not being pompous. If you are perceiving what I said is the same what others have said, that maybe us of a different taste in movie scripts see the same thing in Avatar, or is that a lack of something.. you decide.

            I stand by what I think about the movie… and I am now hearing the same words echoed in the latest podcast in slice of sci fi show..(http://www.sliceofscifi.com/). go listen to the latest voice mail show… they are saying the same things I did weeks ago. Again no right or wrong HERE, just a view. If you cant accept others views and have to insult people, maybe you should not comment.

          • Jeff (T.O.O.)

            I merely “reacted” to you because you’re rude. As for wasting space, well you and I are doing rather well, aren’t we? I can see that I didn’t enlighten you. I don’t care to. Just when I see someone acting like you do, I’ll let them know.

            “As for anger, read what you write….”. Uh, I pretty much know how I feel at any given moment. If I said I wasn’t writing my reply in anger… then I wasn’t. But now, I’m getting a little ticked off at your arrogance. (Self check: Yep, I actually am ticked off, so that’s what I said.)

  • MC Spearing

    I’m an old guy, retired military officer, insular and inured to a world that often as not either frightens or outrages. I mutter and putter around my “mancave” doing my own thing, surly as a brown recluse. Politically cynical and sometimes suspicious, I practically never “gush” over anything. But this … THIS! What a spectacular entertainment earthquake AVATAR is. I see the story as a SciFi embellishment the Captain John Smith and Pocahontas story, staged in a bigger-than-life (and more beautiful) world called Pandora. I implore anyone and everyone who has not seen the 3D version of AVATAR (mine left no headaches or any such discomfort) to drop what they are doing and go. Go! Go! Go! It’s the best bang for my movie buck that I’ve seen for several years … maybe ever. This masterpiece — how do you say it? — Blew my socks clean off!

  • BeccaM

    My spouse and I tried to see Avatar on Christmas day — and alas were disappointed because the theater was packed solid.

    So we waited a few days, were going to wait until after New Years — but I couldn’t hang on, after the raving reviews of good friends. I went on the 29th…but by myself because spouse wasn’t feeling well. I usually don’t mind seeing movies twice and had a feeling this one would bear another viewing.

    I went to one of those upgraded theaters, with the IMAX screen and superb sound, and rather plush chairs. 3D, of course.

    I walked out three hours later simply stunned. Yeah, yeah — simplistic storyline, but I didn’t care. Avatar is simply the best film I have ever seen in my 46 year life.

    I love SF; it’s solid science fiction. I love strong female leads; I grinned like a loon when I saw Grace driving her own Stanford-emblazoned Avatar, and knew she wasn’t just a background character. I love imagination; the whole world of Pandora is beyond that mere term. I love gorgeous visuals, and every color-soaked bioluminescent frame was a feast to the eyes. And yes, the 3D does take a touch of getting used to…but after a short while, you’re right there.

    As I said, I left the theater feeling stunned. A week later, I took my partner and watched as she had the same look in her eyes when we left together. Glad I went the 2nd time, too.

    If they have 3D Blu-ray soon and Avatar is released in that form, I think we may need to do some upgrades on our home theater…

    • Denis.G

      I couldn’t agree with you more. It was a spiritual movie going experience for me. Oh by the way HD 3D TV’s are coming out this year, look it up.