SciFiCool.com

A Terra Nova Review, or, Why The Teenage Kid Gotta be so Predictably Annoying?

Nix September 26, 2011

Terra Nova TV Series PosterDear Hollywood: despite what you may think, not every teenage boy out there is an annoying little prick suffering from uncontrollable, mysterious teen angst. And certainly not after you’ve sent him a gazillion million years into the past through a fancy schmancy time portal/gateway doohickey, and to a world surrounded by mysterious wonders, dino-friggin’-saurs, and the like.

Other than that, there’s a lot to like about FOX’s new sci-fi/dino show “Terra Nova”, but also a lot to groan about. “Terra Nova” is a show that is so expensive per episode it’s rumored that a first born is sacrificed each time a new episode is shot. That may be a tad hyperbolic. A tad…

Set a hundred or so years in the future, on a planet Earth where the shit has royally hit the fan thanks to our poor environmental management (i.e. Al Gore was right), humanity now wallows in pollution as if the entire world was Los Angeles. The Shannons, led by Narcotics cop Jim (Jason O’Mara), are a naughty family. When we first meet them, Jim and wife Elizabeth (Shelley Conn) have defied global law by having a third kid. (Apparently the future operates under very strict China-like law that a family can only have two kids each.) For the crime, Jim is locked up. Well, he also did punch a couple of cops, so there’s that, too.

Shelley Conn, Jason O'Mara, Landon Liboiron and Naomi Scott in Terra Nova TV Series

Flash forward to two years later, and Elizabeth and her kids (two of them, anyway — awkward brainiac daughter Maddy (Naomi Scott) and rebel-without-a-clue son Josh (Landon Liboiron, soon to be the scourge — and dare I say, delight — of “Terra Nova” TV recappers everywhere)) have been chosen to travel back in time to Terra Nova, a camp billions of years in the past (in dinosaur land) where humanity is getting a fresh start. In order to reunite before it’s too late, Jim breaks out of prison, grabs the third kid, and makes a run for the time machine doohickey. And yes, in the future breaking out of a maximum security prison, skirting the security at the hub of all human salvation is a cinch, because ol Jim barely breaks a sweat doing both.

I guess that’s why they call it science fiction, right?

Anyhoo, now safe in the past, the Shannons come under the authority of the military badass Nathaniel Taylor (“Avatar’s” Stephen Lang, doing essentially a variation of his “Avatar” character minus the genocidal tendencies), the first man who ever went through the time machine 7 years earlier. The past is rosy and filled with natural wonders, dinosaurs that snack on the overflowing vegetation, as well as a splinter group of future refugees called the Sixers — one of the groups that came through the time machine that have broken away and have a super secret agenda that no one knows about. Or at least, until in future episodes when all is revealed. Or some such.

Stephen Lang in Terra Nova TV Series

With two hours and change to play with (including commercials), the “Terra Nova” pilot does a fare job establishing its world, past and present. The future stuff looks great, even if the scripting is less than stellar. Again, it’s simply laughable how easily Jim busts out of prison (we don’t even see him do it) and sneaks his way into the time machine hub. There is supposed to be a super duper major surprise once the family arrives at Terra Nova, but the first 5 or so minutes pretty much gave that away. I hear a lot of the pilot has been retooled, with reshoots added for clarity. This would explain why the pilot essentially stabbed itself in the back with the third kid plot.

Once in “Terra Nova”, there is the usual assortment of characters, interpersonal conflicts, and the like. Teenager Josh goes full-blown dick and begins bucking authority at every turn. Apparently having just stepped through a time machine that took him back billions of years into the past really didn’t make much of an impression on the little tyke. Before you can shout “generic and wholly predictable Hollywood TV writing”, Josh has hooked up with a local girl (Allison Miller) and escaped from the well-guarded encampment to make merry outside with a bunch of other similarly bored teenagers. Because, you know, the fact that they are billions of years in the past and thus surrounded by dangerous, flesh-chomping dinosaurs really didn’t make much of an impression on these brats. Sigh. Stab me in the eyes now, please.

Allison Miller and Landon Liboiron in Terra Nova TV Series

Without a doubt, if you enjoyed the “Terra Nova” pilot at all, it’s thanks to great work by Lang and O’Mara. The two manly men are surprisingly like-minded at first, though there will obviously be differences in the future. Not quite as successful is O’Mara’s (shockingly lack of) chemistry with leading lady Shelley Conn, playing a wife he loves so much he bucked global law by having a third kid with, the result of which has them hiding the kid like she’s a lost puppy when people show up at their tiny little apartment. Talk about dead on arrival. Conn could have been O’Mara’s platonic next door neighbor or big sister for all the heat the two generates. Hell, even oldest daughter Maddy’s awkward flirtations with a local hunky soldier is more believable than this married couple. What a major miscasting. More believable is Jim’s relationship with his daughters.

If you like dinosaurs, though, “Terra Nova’s” got you covered. There are friendly dinosaurs. Dangerous dinosaurs. Huge dinosaurs. Small dinosaurs. Chasing dinosaurs. Dinosaurs that are freaky scary as hell. Dinosaurs that are downright cute. You name it, they’ve spent money making it for you in “Terra Nova”. (Thus, the film’s huge per-episode budget.) The problem, of course, is how long that novelty will last. You can only be pre-occupied by the dinos for so long, after all. Right now, I can’t tell if “Terra Nova” has enough in the tank to make you care about the people, or the unfolding conspiracy angle between the folks at Terra Nova and those mysterious Sixer types led by Christine Adams.

Lang’s character certainly has plenty of arc in him, and here’s hoping Jim becomes just as complicated in future episodes. Come on, he can’t be this great, can he? Our hero is the perfect husband, father, and cop, for God’s sake. Let’s see some shades! That, and Josh and his merry band of generic teenage buddies get eaten by a dinosaur in the first few minutes of next week’s episode…

Stephen Lang, Shelley Conn, Jason O'Mara, Mido Hamada, Allison Miller, Landon Liboiron and Naomi Scott in Terra Nova TV Series


  • Some Guy

     Hey man, first time/long time. I moderately enjoyed this ep, I mean enough to watch it again. The one thing tho, it was hard enough to get over the formulaic writing and bad acting, but to get over the gaping plot whole in the first episode, that may prove harder in the long run (SPOILER WARNING if you have not watched the pilot yet): They establish that the “time fissure” is a one way doorway to 85 million years in the past, and that it is “a new time stream” what they don’t explain is how they knew it is 85m years ago, and not just a way of vaporizing people and things (seems like a rather inefficient way to cull the population). Sure, I get that they might explain this in the future for us viewers, but wouldn’t the people going through the stargate (see what I did there?) want to know what is on the other side? 

     Like I said, I will probably keep watching, but If I had a choice I would watch shows with better writing like (imo) SG:U or Caprica. Sadly, I do not.

    • http://www.beyondhollywood.com/ Nix

      Not a whole lot of options out there, alas…

  • Bill T.

    I’ve been a science fiction fan for over 40 years. I watched the show last night and liked it well enough.  I will continue to watch the show, because that’s what fans do (It’s in our contract.  We have to watch).  I hope it gets better, but the pilot did not give me the same thrill that the pilot episodes of Firefly or Fringe gave me.  We’ll see what happens.

    P.S. The X Files thrilled me also.

    • http://www.beyondhollywood.com/ Nix

      Sad, isn’t it? We’ll watch, because there’s not much out there to watch otherwise… Sigh.

  • Andy

    Actually I found the whole family annoying, straight from the basic premise they were somehow special and could have a third child in a future where there was population control for a reason. Lost my sympathy straight away. Then the son turned into a prick…

    • strange_aeons

      i just watched the first episode last night and feel the same way, these people dont feel like a family, they feel like people playing a part. and they wanted a third child so badly, but didnt think through what kind of a life that child would have being constantly hidden in the ventilation like that. all the stereotype teen angst was stupid too. so these kids go out to their hidden stash of moonshine and get wasted with dinosaurs lurking about? lame, incredibly lame.

  • Vickevlar

    I liked the performance by Lang and O’Mara but the pilot episode was a mild disappointment.  The plot holes were pretty large… even for sci-fi.  I will give this another couple of episodes in hopes that the larger story arc will catch my interest.

  • Kate

    Thanks for pointing out the annoying teenage guy.  I would have enjoyed the premier more without that utter predictability.  It was totally cringe-worthy and pretty much ruined the entire episode for me.  I know that’s rather melodramatic, but it was just too cliche.  I might tune back in, but one scene of that kid being his unfoundedly boorish self and I’m done.

  • comanche07

    Im from Coventry England,after reading the above reviews, im somewhat confused as to the negative responses over certain shows.turn the channel over,watch something else, dont bitch about certain shows, writing about their flaws…get a life!
    Terra Nova went down well over here, I gues us Brits dont analyse the way other countries do.Take Terra for what it is, an entertaining sci-fi show, so what if the family is dysfunctional, the kid annoying, isnt that life now.
    We liked it over here, yet surprise,surprise, its been cancelled, why bother watching any show that may be doomed to fail.Are the demographic scores that useful, the studios realy on them to either, continue, or cancel shows.
    Im a sci-fi fan, I love movies and tv shows, as does my family and friends, yet we get so pissed off when the shows we start to get into get the chop.

Login to your account

Can't remember your Password ?

Register for this site!